Becerra Faces Sharp Criticism in California Governor’s Race

Daniel Kimani

Xavier Becerra's leadership at HHS takes center stage in the California primary, with rivals questioning his pandemic response and trustworthiness in a heated race for governor.

Xavier Becerra, the front-runner in California's gubernatorial primary, has come under intense criticism from his political opponents, particularly for his tenure as Secretary of Health and Human Services under the Biden administration. Critics, including Democratic rival Tom Steyer, have accused him of mismanagement during the pandemic and blamed him for issues related to unaccompanied migrant children, including the claim that 85,000 minors were lost in the sponsor system. These criticisms highlight questions about his credibility and trustworthiness.

However, supporters such as Ron Klain, Biden's former chief of staff, have defended Becerra, pointing to significant accomplishments like expanding healthcare coverage and reducing prescription drug costs. Klain emphasized that Becerra's lower profile during the pandemic was due to his late confirmation and the prominent role of other public health officials, such as Dr. Anthony Fauci. Despite the scrutiny, the latest polls show Becerra leading the race but with rivals close behind.

What criticisms has Becerra faced during California's primary?

Becerra has been criticized for his HHS performance, particularly during the pandemic and his handling of unaccompanied migrant children. Rivals like Tom Steyer have labeled him as incompetent and mismanaging critical issues.

Divisive Opinions and Political Attacks

The criticism against Becerra has been amplified by campaign tactics and media commentary. For example, mailers from Steyer’s campaign label him as incompetent and cite harsh remarks from former Biden administration officials, including a quoted statement from Susan Rice calling Becerra an 'idiot.' Much of the criticism, however, has come from anonymous sources, making voters question the motivations behind these attacks. On the other hand, defenders like Neera Tanden, Biden’s Domestic Policy Council head, have refuted these claims, describing them as baseless and emphasizing accomplishments in healthcare and policy reforms achieved under Becerra's tenure.

Reports also suggest that tensions with figures like Susan Rice, who reportedly designed the migrant accommodation plan that Becerra inherited, may reflect personal animosity rather than objective policy disagreements. This has further complicated public perceptions of Becerra’s record as his leadership and decision-making face mounting scrutiny in the final stretch of the primary campaign.

Implications for California's Political Landscape

For California’s cities and municipal leaders, the outcome of this gubernatorial race carries significant stakes. Decisions made by Becerra, Steyer, or any eventual winner will impact key urban issues such as public health funding, housing policies, and immigration approaches. Mayors and city officials are closely watching how candidates position themselves on urban challenges, particularly in managing homelessness and healthcare access , two areas central to California's governance debates.

Becerra’s background, from his extensive legal and political career to his federal agency tenure, suggests a methodical approach that could resonate well with city leaders accustomed to dealing with bureaucratic complexities. However, the unresolved questions about his management style might give local governments pause. Municipal leaders should assess how each candidate’s track record aligns with their cities’ pressing needs, especially as campaign rhetoric often diverges from practical governing.

Questions That Matter

What did Susan Rice allegedly call Xavier Becerra?

Susan Rice allegedly referred to Xavier Becerra as an 'idiot,' a remark highlighted in Tom Steyer's campaign materials. This comment has been used to criticize Becerra's competence during his tenure at HHS.

How does Neera Tanden defend Becerra's record?

Neera Tanden defends Xavier Becerra by dismissing criticisms as baseless and emphasizing his achievements in healthcare and policy reforms. She highlights his accomplishments while leading the Department of Health and Human Services.